20 MARKS

Don't write (Don't write seein VAJIRAM & RAV! roe this part) 9 Kirti and Nilesh childhood trends from a small town in Maharashtra had always stood by each other through life's ups and downs Both dreamed of becoming doctors. but their academic tourneys diverged. Kirti cleared the NEFT exam in her first attempt and joined a reputed medical college in Mumbai. Nilesh despite being equally capable had to drop a year due to family responsibilities and joined the same college a year later By the time Nilesh reached his final year Kirti had already begun her internship and was appointed as the student coordingior for the Wpoomuns final year practical examinations. In this role she was responsible for coordinating logistics between faculty and students managing lab schedules and assisting with administrative picpanitiony icluding conlidcntial Waks like pholocopy ig and slong cAwminulon materials Around the same time Nilesh confided in her that he was on the verge of mental and emotional collapse. His father's prolonged illness had drained the family financially and he was juggling studies with d paiictine job. He admutted that the upcoming practicals would not only destroy his morale but also crush his family's hope. Kirti's parents recalling how Nilesh's family had once helped them dunng a emsis gently reminded fier thar "this tight be the time fo return the favour" Kart herself was torn she felt a deep personal sense of sratitude. Yet she was also acutely aware of the ¢thical responsibyities ©. Any breach of protocol inicntional or otherwise could compromise the faimess of the examination process and damage her integrity. Her mentoghad explicitly warmed her that even the perception of impropriety could lead to an ingwiry and serious consequences (a) What are the ethical dilemmas before Kirti in this case? (b) Identify and evaluate the various Courses of action available before Kuri (c) If you were in Kirti's shoes which course of action would you choose and why? (20 marks 250 words)

Topper: Reshma Nivetha · AIR 498 · 2025 · Page 32